Thought Punks

Tag: Criticism

Secrets in the Static: The Ghost Town of Wavelength
This entry is part 4 of 4 in the series Free Games
Crowdfunding completed! Preview version now available.

A TTRPG idea inspired by Lynchian horror, embodying surreal suburban dread and the unsettling blend of media and reality. Pulled from my playtesting slush pile in memory of David Lynch. Shared under a Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0 license. Credit “Rev from Thought Punks”. This was a beta playtest module. The formatting and presentation style reflects that. This also stands out as an example of minimalist worldbuilding.

Core Concept

The town of Wavelength exists in a strange limbo, an idyllic Upstate New York town that vanished from official records and maps in the early 1990s. Its existence has become a half-remembered myth, whispered about on long road trips and crackling through static on AM radio. Some claim to pick up ghostly broadcasts near where Wavelength supposedly stood, hearing fragments of soap operas, weather reports, or personal messages from those who lived there.

For those inside Wavelength, the town remains suspended in eerie perfection, a postcard-perfect snapshot of 90s small-town life. Quaint diners, artisanal crafts, and warm neighbors project an air of nostalgia… but the town has secrets.

Recently, televisions and radios have been infected with an omnipresent, enigmatic signal. Cryptic ads interrupt every broadcast, whispering impossible truths and surreal commands. Music swells out of nowhere, quelling any thoughts of leaving the town. Cryptic commercials, haunting soap operas, and surreal PSAs suggest the Static’s growing control. Some residents are even rumored to have vanished, replaced by eerie replicas speaking only in disjointed TV dialogue.

Players, each tied to the signal in a deeply personal way, must navigate Wavelength’s shifting reality, uncovering its secrets while holding onto their crumbling identities.

Player Hook

Each character has a personal connection to the signal, making their investigation deeply intimate. These connections could include:
- Hearing a lost loved one’s voice in a garbled ad, pleading for help.
- Seeing impossible depictions of their own future in soap opera snippets.
- Receiving unsettling, tailored messages through radio jingles.
The signal lures players in, offering tantalizing truths and supernatural powers. But the closer they get, the more it rewrites their memories, relationships, and even their physical forms.

Key Themes
- Identity Erosion: The signal corrupts characters’ self-perception and memories, forcing them to question who they are.
- Surreal Suburban Dread: Wavelength’s small-town charm contrasts with growing paranoia and uncanny horrors.
- Media and Reality Bleed: Broadcasts shape reality, and characters must interact with these phenomena to uncover the truth.
- Ambiguous Agency: Is the signal sentient? Malicious? Or just a reflection of their deepest flaws?
Gameplay Framework

Core Mechanic: The 3d6 Roll

Every action involves rolling 3d6, with each die serving a specific purpose (called “flavors” or dice labels):
- Degree Die: Measures success (1 = partial success, 6 = overwhelming success).
- Cost Die: Determines complications or costs (1 = severe, 6 = none).
- Static Die: Reflects distortion by the signal (1 = surreal, 6 = mundane).
Modifiers are added based on traits like Nature, Profession, Hobbies, and Quirks. After rolling, apply modifiers and interpret the results based on the fiction.

Character Creation
- Hook: What draws you to the Static? What do you see or hear in it?
- Nature: The core of who you are. Examples: “Survivor,” “Protector,” or “Dreamer.”
  - When in alignment: Add +2 to die of choice after rolling.
  - When in conflict: Add +3 to the Cost Die.
- Profession: Your role in Wavelength (e.g., librarian, mechanic, bartender).
  - When relevant: After rolling, rearrange the dice in any order.
- Hobbies (pick 3): Passions or skills unrelated to your profession.
  - When relevant: Add +1 to any one die after rolling.
- Quirks (pick 2): Unusual traits, some mundane, some supernatural.
  - At the start of a scene, roll 2d6, assigning one die to each Quirk. On a 6, that Quirk activates (examples: eerie theme music plays, your body distorts to walk on all fours, or you compulsively spout jingles).
- Background Details (write 3): Relationships, memories, or personal details grounding your character.
Mechanics of the Static

Static Exposure

When exposed to the signal, the GM determines the intensity of the interaction:
- Minor Exposure: Roll 1d6.
- Moderate Exposure: Roll 2d6.
- Major Exposure: Roll 3d6.
Gain 1 Static Point for every die that rolls 4 or higher.
- Minor: Listening to a cryptic ad on the radio or stopping briefly to watch a flickering TV broadcasting surreal images.
- Moderate: Watching a full broadcast that seems to address your concerns personally or deeply analyzing a broadcast for meaning or clues.
- Major: Being the focus of the signal’s direct attention, such as being spoken to directly by an anchor on a TV or being caught in a scene that is completed distorted into TV reality by the Static.
Powers from the Static

Characters with Static Points gain access to the hidden signs in the signal. These powers come in minor and major categories, reflecting their risk and scope.

Minor Powers (2 Dice)

Minor powers unlock at 3 Static Points. These are small, reality-bending effects that grant brief advantages. Roll 2d6 when using a minor power. Gain 1 Static Point for every die that rolls 4 or higher.

Examples of Minor Powers:
- Alter a Small Detail: Change a single object or memory in the immediate area (e.g., a flickering light turns solid red, a door briefly becomes a wall, or someone remembers an argument as a cordial conversation).
- Daring Insight: By bravely facing the signal with full attention for a second, you can glimpse unnoticed clues, hidden areas, torrid affairs, and other secrets in a location.
- Eerie Influence: Convince someone to act out of character using subtle, surreal persuasion.
Major Powers (4 Dice)

Major powers unlock at 6 Static points. These allow significant manipulations of reality at a cost. Roll 4d6 when using a major power. Gain 1 Static Point for every die that rolls 4 or higher.

Examples of Major Powers:
- Rewrite Reality: Change a large element in the environment, like turning a road into a river, erasing or introducing an NPC into a scene, or completely change the dynamic of a family feud.
- Erase or Implant Memories: Target one person, radically altering their memory of an event or relationship.
- Surreal Projection: Create a temporary illusion or construct that others perceive as real.
At 9 Static Points, only roll 1d6 for minor powers and 2d6 for major powers. Also ignore minor exposures and roll one less die for moderate and major exposures. The Static has begun to embrace you and it flows easily, too easily, through you. It constantly whispers in your mind, even far away from any screens or speakers, a portion of the signal finding its way directly to increasingly distorted soul.

Spending Static Points

Players can spend Static Points only during interludes between scenes to deliberately rewrite aspects of their character. This process represents an attempt to resist, or embrace, the signal’s influence, but it comes with risks.
- Determine Spending Limit: Roll 1d6. The result is the maximum number of Static Points you can spend during this interlude.
- Choose Rewrites: Spend points based on the following costs:
  - 1 Point: Change one Hobby or Quirk.
  - 2 Points: Change your Profession or a Background Detail.
  - Nature: Cannot be changed unless the character hits the Static Limit and is fully rewritten.
Roll a d6 for each thing chosen to be changed. On 1-3, change it to reflect growing closer to the Static. On 4-6, change it to reflect your personal will or what you think more truly reflects who you were before the Static trapped and rewrote the town. For signal-influenced changes, they are also accompanied by physical changes, initially simple things like hairstyles and clothing choices but eventually escalating into radical differences, almost becoming a different person.

Static Limit

If you reach 13 Static Points, you must rewrite your entire character, even your Nature and complete appearance. Everything but one background detail, a tenuous tie to the previous you, is altered. When rewriting your character, change things to what you think the Static wants or what is further away from your true self.

Assorted Advice

Spending Static Points

Treat spending as a chance for characters to direct their transformation. Frame it as a double-edged sword: while they can resist, they can never truly escape the signal’s grip. There is a random chance whether the transformations follow their will or lean into the mysterious goals of the Static. Use rewrites to develop surreal or thematic elements that deepen the story.

Using Powers

Encourage players to experiment with powers early, reinforcing the temptation to draw on the signal. As powers escalate, introduce moral and narrative consequences. For example, a small illusion might merely confuse a bystander, but a major reality shift could incidentally rewrite someone else’s identity entirely.

Exposure Rolls

Use exposure rolls to emphasize the dangers of interacting with the signal. Minor exposure should feel subtle and unnerving, while major exposure should be dramatic and unrelenting.

Dynamic Worldbuilding

The town of Wavelength evolves alongside the characters’ investigations. GMs should introduce surreal events tied to the signal’s influence, such as:
- The Laugh Track Incident: Characters hear sitcom laugh tracks during conversations, even in empty spaces.
- The Soap Opera Shift: Players reenact scenes from the signal’s broadcasts, with scripted lines and actions.
- The Product That Doesn’t Exist: A commercial compels a resident to build or sell a nonsensical item.
- The Uncanny Broadcast: A news anchor appears on every screen, reading out the characters’ secrets.
- The Repetition Effect: Players relive the same scene repeatedly, each iteration growing more distorted.
Collaboration and Mystery

Encourage players to work together to piece together clues, but introduce conflicting memories and perspectives to create tension. The truth should remain ambiguous, with players shaping its interpretation through their actions.

Gameplay Toolkit

This is a toolkit to help you craft a surreal, Lynchian experience in Wavelength. It includes templates for the town’s evolution, pacing advice, key events, escalating exposure scenes, and sample NPCs. Use this to guide the play through the town’s eerie descent into the unknown.

Templates for Wavelength’s Evolution

Wavelength begins as a nostalgic, picturesque town, but as the Static’s influence grows, it fractures into a surreal nightmare. Use the following phases to structure its progression.

Phase 1: Postcard Perfection
- Tone: Idyllic and welcoming with subtle undercurrents of unease.
- Environment: Pristine sidewalks, smiling neighbors, cheerful radio hosts.
- Signal Presence: Minor and eerie, like brief ads with strange phrasing, static interruptions.
- NPC Behavior: Friendly but slightly off, as if reading from a script.
Event Examples:
- A TV plays an old soap opera where one character eerily resembles a player.
- A commercial for a product the players owned as children plays on every screen in a diner.
- An NPC starts speaking only in television and radio quotes.
Phase 2: Fractured Reality
- Tone: The charm cracks; paranoia grows.
- Environment: Familiar locations subtly shift, streets curve impossibly, clocks show contradictory times.
- Signal Presence: More pervasive, NPCs speak in advertising jingles or reenact full scenes from TV.
- NPC Behavior: Neighbors act erratically, forgetting recent events or treating strangers as family.
Event Examples:
- A pedestrian repeatedly crosses the same intersection in different outfits.
- A weather report describes exact player actions happening as it airs.
- Reality’s color become over-saturated and everyone is dressed like a 50s sitcom.
Phase 3: Full Static Takeover
- Tone: The town becomes a surreal, shifting maze.
- Environment: Familiar landmarks melt into distorted landscapes, streets loop infinitely, diners stretch into hallways.
- Signal Presence: Ubiquitous, broadcasts directly interact with players and reshape reality.
- NPC Behavior: Most NPCs behave like TV archetypes, repeating lines or freezing when not “on screen.”
Event Examples:
- A sitcom laugh track loudly plays during a tense argument.
- An anchorperson on every screen reveals players’ private thoughts.
- The “channel changes” and the scene abrupt shifts completely in location, action, and tone.
Pacing Advice
- Establish Normalcy: Spend time grounding players in Wavelength’s initial perfection. Let them connect with NPCs and locations to make later distortions more impactful.
- Introduce the Signal Gradually: Begin with brief, eerie phenomena before escalating into more overt reality distortions.
- Create Interludes: Allow quiet moments between scenes for players to process changes, strategize, and rewrite their characters if desired.
- Escalate Tension Slowly: Build unease steadily, reserving major distortions for climactic scenes or critical narrative beats.
Key Events

Intersperse events like these throughout the campaign to maintain momentum:
- The First Broadcast: A character hears their name in a commercial or sees an unsettling reflection on TV.
- The Looping Scene: A day or interaction repeats with small, chilling changes each time.
- The Uncanny Anchor: A news anchor delivers a message addressed directly to the players, predicting their actions.
- NPC Vanishing: A well-known NPC disappears, replaced by a scripted replica or a memory gap no one else notices.
- The Static Ritual: TVs across Wavelength broadcast a synchronized, incomprehensible ceremony.
Escalating Exposure Scenes

Use these examples to reflect the growing influence of the Static and its effects on characters.

Minor Exposure
- Hearing one’s own voice on the radio, finishing sentences the player hasn’t said yet.
- A flickering TV shows a childhood memory in grainy black-and-white.
- Static floods a nearby screen when a player approaches.
Moderate Exposure
- A commercial plays, tailored to a player’s fear or desire, offering cryptic advice.
- A player’s reflection on a blank TV begins mimicking their inner thoughts.
- An NPC freezes mid-sentence, then resumes, as if nothing happened.
Major Exposure
- The signal addresses a player directly, calling them by name or revealing secrets.
- Time loops, forcing players to repeat actions while the environment changes around them.
- The characters find themselves in a TV show set, complete with laugh tracks and canned applause.
Sample NPCs

Populate Wavelength with eerie, Lynchian characters who evolve alongside the town. Examples:

Donna Whitfield, the Diner Waitress

Donna is cheerful, chatty, and knows everyone’s name and favorite dish, even visitors who’ve just arrived in Wavelength. She seems to embody small-town hospitality, always smiling and ready with a pot of coffee. As the signal spreads, her behavior grows increasingly unsettling: she begins repeating phrases verbatim from old sitcoms, her expressions freezing into unnatural, static smiles. When players interact with her late at night, she might serve invisible (but real) food or speak in voices that clearly aren’t hers, like a television switching channels mid-sentence.

Mr. Stanton, the Radio Host

With his warm, folksy voice, Mr. Stanton is a constant presence in Wavelength. His AM radio show is equal parts town gossip, classic hits, and quirky commentary, making him beloved by locals. However, as the signal intensifies, his broadcasts take a darker turn. He begins sharing cryptic messages that seem meant specifically for the players, warning them of dangers, revealing their secrets, or hinting at the signal’s origin. Occasionally, his voice is overlaid with static, or the broadcast cuts to chilling advertisements for products that don’t exist. By the time the players uncover more about him, they may realize that no one has ever actually seen Mr. Stanton in person.

Hank and Betty Rosewood, the Retirees

The Rosewoods are Wavelength’s quintessential elderly couple: inseparable, amiable, and endlessly curious about others’ lives. They love hosting impromptu garden parties and sharing stories of their travels (despite never leaving town). As the signal grows, the couple becomes increasingly surreal, sometimes speaking in perfect unison or finishing each other’s sentences with eerie precision. Eventually, the players may discover them standing in their living room, completely motionless, as if frozen mid-conversation. Later still, they might encounter them as life-sized mannequins, their features disturbingly lifelike. If “activated” by the signal, they resume speaking, but their dialogue loops unnervingly, repeating old conversations.

Mrs. Lindley, the School Librarian

Strict but kind-hearted, Mrs. Lindley always seems to be shelving books when the players enter. As the Static grows, the books in her library start whispering secrets, and she begins to speak in riddles, referencing events that haven’t yet occurred, or that never will. Eventually, she seems to vanish, leaving the library eerily empty, yet somehow always open. However, anyone making too much noise or disrespecting the space will be hushed by a disembodied voice, or worse.

Caleb Fischer, the Town Drifter

A quiet man with a perpetual cigarette and a knack for appearing wherever he’s least expected. Caleb knows things he shouldn’t and shares cryptic warnings that feel more like prophecies. As the signal intensifies, Caleb begins to glitch, flickering like an old TV image or speaking in overlapping voices. Eventually he begins to randomly appear and disappear in places, a full staticky flickering image of a man who increasingly ceases to resemble the original Caleb.

Kelly-Ann Fletcher, the Realtor

Bright and relentlessly optimistic, Kelly-Ann insists Wavelength is the perfect place to live. She tirelessly promotes homes, even those now clearly abandoned or inexplicably distorted. Over time, her “For Sale” signs start appearing in impossible places (inside locked rooms, floating in midair), and her smile grows unsettlingly wide, as if stretched beyond human capability. She begins to promise “brand new homes” available in “The Hidden Vistas”, with home viewers vanishing with Ms. Fletcher promising with 100 voices of a choir they’re “forever happy in their forever home”.

Clarifying Endgame Options

The endgame of Wavelength is deliberately ambiguous, allowing the GM and players to shape the resolution collaboratively. Here are four possible outcomes, each with variations, to inspire meaningful choices while maintaining the surreal tone.

Escaping Wavelength

The players discover a way to leave the town, severing their connection to the signal. However, escape comes with heavy consequences:
- Memory Price: To leave, the players must give up key aspects of their identities, such as memories of loved ones, their professions, or even their Natures. They will need to abandon all their loved ones and any chance of recovering their true self.
- Reality Divergence: Upon escaping, players realize the world outside Wavelength is subtly wrong: unrecognizable landmarks, altered history, or loved ones who claim the players never existed.
- Lingering Static: The signal has permanently marked them, manifesting in small, surreal glitches in their lives. They might see brief flashes of Wavelength on their TVs or hear its broadcasts late at night.
Confronting the Signal

The players pursue the source of the signal, uncovering its true nature. This ending offers closure, or deeper mystery. Possible natures of the broadcast to discover and confront:
- Government Experiment: A covert project designed to manipulate reality via media went out of control.
- Sentient Broadcast: The signal is alive, seeking to reshape the world in its image.
- Forbidden Family Ritual: The signal stems from an ancient, familial pact to preserve Wavelength at the cost of its residents’ humanity.
- The Incomprehensible: The signal is a manifestation of reality’s underlying fragility or some unknowable Thing From Beyond, offering no clear answers.
The Choice:
- Shut It Down: Attempt to destroy the signal, but at the cost of their own existence or trapping others in the process.
- Fuse With It: Embrace the signal, merging with it to become its new stewards, spreading its influence further.
- Compromise: Negotiate with the signal to stabilize Wavelength, but allow its continued existence at the edges of reality.
Embracing Transformation

The players give in to the signal, allowing it to fully rewrite them and their environment.
- Sublime Union: The characters become one with the signal, losing their original identities but gaining a surreal, godlike understanding of reality.
- Wavelength Rewritten: The town stabilizes under the signal’s control, transformed into a surreal utopia or dystopia.
- Sacrifice for Others: The players stay behind, fully consumed by the signal, but in doing so, they protect the rest of the world from its spread.
Bodhisattva Vow

The players discover their true original identities and a way to escape Wavelength, but instead, they choose to remain in the town to awaken and free others from the Static’s grip. This choice comes with significant consequences:
- Self-Sacrifice: The players give up their chance to escape, staying behind to help those trapped by the signal. Their own identities and memories begin to erode further as they fight to free others, risking becoming part of the Static forever.
- Transformative Struggle: As they try to awaken others, they face increasing distortions to their reality and personal selves, potentially losing their original essence in the process.
- Lingering Hope: Despite the risks, their actions might lead to moments of clarity or breakthroughs, where some residents momentarily escape the signal’s control, but at the cost of their own stability.
Additional Guidance for GMs

Establish early on what motivates each character to engage with the signal (finding a loved one, escaping Wavelength, or uncovering the truth). Use these motivations to shape the endgame conflicts.

Introduce dilemmas that force players to weigh personal goals against collective outcomes. For example, escaping may require sacrificing an NPC who is too deeply tied to the signal.

Keep the truth about the signal flexible until late in the campaign. Allow players’ theories and actions to shape the final reveal.

Offer answers that resolve immediate questions but introduce new mysteries. For example, players might destroy a device broadcasting the signal but find evidence of a second, more sinister source.

Encourage players to discuss their goals and weigh the consequences of their choices as a group. Use interludes to highlight individual transformations and their impact on the team.

Present multiple paths in the final session, but make it clear that every choice carries irreversible consequences.

The endgame should feel surreal and emotionally charged. Use shifting environments, cryptic NPCs, and nonlinear events to heighten the tension. Allow scenes to loop, merge, or collapse into chaos as the signal reaches its peak, creating a dreamlike sense of inevitability.

The endgame of Wavelength is less about providing closure and more about forcing players to grapple with transformation, sacrifice, and ambiguity. Regardless of the chosen ending, leave enough unanswered questions for players to linger on the experience long after the final scene fades to static.

Crowdfunding completed! Preview version now available.

Share this with friends:
Related posts:
January 18, 2025
In Defense of Optional Rules
This entry is part 1 of 3 in the series TTRPG Defenses
Expanding, Not Complicating, the RPG Experience

Optional rules and alternative subsystems often find themselves at the center of heated debates in the tabletop RPG community. Some call them unnecessary fluff, others claim they confuse players, and a vocal few see them as evidence of flawed design. But are these critiques really fair? Or are they missing something important?

Optional rules aren’t there to drown games in needless complexity or make things harder to play. They’re about possibility. They open doors, not just for tweaking mechanics but for crafting an experience that feels unique to your group. Whether it’s empowering storytellers to deepen immersion or letting players shape gameplay around their preferences, optional rules are more than just extras… they’re bridges to new ideas and richer experiences.

In this article, we’re going to challenge the common criticisms of optional rules and unpack their true value. Whether you’re a veteran GM or a total newcomer, understanding how optional rules work and what they bring to the table can shift your perspective, and maybe even elevate your game. Let’s dive in and explore why these often-misunderstood elements are the unsung heroes of tabletop RPGs.

Complexity as a Feature, Not a Bug

Optional rules often get dismissed as making things unnecessarily complicated. But complexity isn’t inherently bad! In fact, when handled well, it’s one of a game’s greatest strengths. Optional rules can add layers to the experience, offering groups a chance to explore nuanced decision-making, dive into intricate mechanics, or build out richer storylines. They’re not about piling on confusion; they’re about creating depth where it’s wanted.

The beauty of optional rules is that they’re just that: optional. You’re not forced to engage with them. They sit patiently on the sidelines, ready to be brought into play when your group feels ready for more. For new players, the core rules offer a solid, approachable foundation. As familiarity grows, optional rules become a way to explore new dimensions of the game, adding layers of strategy or storytelling that align with the group’s evolving interests.

This gradual evolution is where optional rules shine. They let the game grow with the group, adapting to your needs and preferences. They don’t just provide a framework for more advanced play; they let you craft an experience that feels like it was built for your table.

The real magic of optional rules comes from their adaptability. Whether it’s introducing a new combat mechanic for more tactical depth or adding a subsystem to track emotional relationships, these rules give you the tools to refine the game as you go. It’s not about overwhelming players, it’s about letting the game unfold in a way that feels natural and rewarding.

A Few Tips: Optional Rules Without Overwhelming

Adding optional rules can feel like walking a tightrope for a lot of gamers. After all, you want to enrich the experience, not drown it in complexity. Here are some tips to introduce them in a way that enhances the game without overwhelming anyone at the table:
- Start Small: Begin with the core rules, especially when playing with new or less experienced players. Let the group master the basics first, then layer in optional rules. They’re there to complement, not overshadow, the foundation of play.
- Explain the Why: When introducing an optional rule, take a moment to explain its purpose. How does it make the game better? Why is it relevant to the story or gameplay? A clear explanation can help players see the value and get excited about the new addition.
- Take It One Rule at a Time: Don’t overwhelm the group with a flood of new rules. Instead, add one at a time and let it settle. This gradual approach keeps things accessible and gives everyone a chance to adapt before moving on to more changes.
- Experiment Before Committing: Optional rules aren’t permanent. Treat them like trial runs; test them in a single session to see how they feel. If they work, great! If not, you can refine or discard them without disrupting the game.
- Prioritize Flow: Optional rules should enhance the experience, not drag it down. If a rule constantly interrupts the game or overcomplicates decisions, it may need tweaking or setting aside altogether. Always prioritize a smooth, engaging play experience.
The secret to integrating optional rules is intention. When added thoughtfully and gradually, they can make the game feel more dynamic, exciting, and personal without overwhelming anyone.

Balance Through Adaptation

Critics often argue that optional rules disrupt balance, introducing chaos into a carefully designed system. But balance in tabletop RPGs is rarely a one-size-fits-all concept. Instead, it’s about harmony, aligning the mechanics with the playstyle and preferences of the group. Optional rules shine because they offer the flexibility to adapt the game to what feels right for each table.

For some groups, balance means streamlined mechanics and fast-paced action. For others, it might involve intricate systems for tactical combat or narrative immersion. Optional rules allow groups to adjust the experience to suit their needs, offering just enough complexity to enhance the game without tipping the scales too far. A well-designed optional rule doesn’t undermine fairness. It enhances it by giving players and GMs the tools to tailor the game to their specific playstyle.

Rather than creating imbalance, optional rules help groups find their own equilibrium. As players grow more familiar with the game, they can selectively introduce new layers of complexity or nuance in ways that feel organic and rewarding. In this sense, the rules evolve alongside the group, ensuring the game remains engaging and fresh without feeling overwhelming.

Ultimately, optional rules aren’t about imposing changes, they’re about offering possibilities. By introducing these elements carefully and thoughtfully, you can strike a balance that feels just right for your table, making the game more dynamic and enjoyable for everyone.

Flexibility Over Fragmentation

A common concern about optional rules in tabletop RPGs is that they might create inconsistency between groups. If every table uses a different mix of rules, won’t the game feel fragmented? While this worry is understandable, it overlooks the core strength of optional rules: flexibility, not fragmentation.

Optional rules are designed to celebrate the diversity of playstyles that make tabletop RPGs so special. Every group is unique, and what works well for one table might not fit another. These rules empower Game Masters (GMs) and players to shape the game to suit their preferences, enhancing the experience instead of limiting it.

Rather than splintering the game, optional rules offer modular tools for customization. They sit alongside the core rules, which remain a consistent foundation for all tables. Whether a group gravitates toward tactical depth, narrative richness, or simplified mechanics, optional rules provide the flexibility to fine-tune the experience while maintaining the integrity of the game’s core.

Far from fragmenting the game, these optional rules unify the experience. They make RPGs more inclusive by allowing groups to tailor the game to their own style, without being bound to a single, rigid “official” approach. When implemented thoughtfully, optional rules serve as a bridge fostering creativity, collaboration, and player engagement without disrupting the game’s core structure.

Calibrating Options To Fit Your Table

Adding optional rules is not just about increasing complexity; it’s about aligning the game with the specific goals and preferences of your group. When introducing these mechanics, think about what you want to achieve and how they can enhance your group’s experience.

Enhancing Player Agency

If your goal is to give players more control over the story, consider adding mechanics that empower them to make impactful decisions. Systems that track character goals, influence world events, or allow players to shape key narrative elements can amplify their sense of agency. Start with simpler mechanics and gradually introduce more complexity as the group becomes comfortable with the new rules.

Deepening Emotional Stakes

Optional rules can also be used to intensify emotional engagement. Mechanics that emphasize relationships, trust, or alliances can deepen the roleplaying experience without overwhelming players. Introduce these rules gradually, linking them naturally to the unfolding narrative. When they emerge in response to character actions and story developments, they feel like an organic part of the experience, rather than an unnecessary complication.

Adapting to Tone and Genre

One of the most powerful aspects of optional rules is their ability to adapt the game to suit a particular tone or genre. A survival mechanic in a horror game, for example, can heighten tension and make every decision feel critical. In contrast, a complex social system might amplify the intrigue in a political drama, giving players new ways to shape the world around them. The key is to select optional rules that align with your group’s desired experience, ensuring that they enhance the story and match the game’s tone.

By introducing optional rules with intention, you are not fragmenting the experience, you are refining it. These rules act as tools that help align the game’s mechanics with your group’s style, creating a dynamic and personalized experience.

Deepening Immersion, Not Breaking It

Some critics argue that adding layers of optional rules risks pulling players out of the narrative, breaking immersion with mechanical distractions. But this perspective overlooks the potential of well-selected optional systems to actually enhance immersion.

Take, for example, a survival mechanic in a horror game. Rather than pulling players out of the story, it increases the tension, making every choice feel critical. Similarly, in a political drama, a detailed social system can deepen roleplay, offering players meaningful ways to influence the world and their relationships. These mechanics don’t derail the narrative; they highlight the aspects of the game that are most important to the group.

Optional rules shine when they complement the game’s tone and genre. Tailoring mechanics to fit the story helps ensure they feel like a natural extension of the narrative, rather than an unwanted distraction. Since these rules are optional, groups have the freedom to select only the systems that enhance their experience, whether it’s managing resources in a survival campaign or deepening character relationships in a story-heavy drama.

When used thoughtfully, optional rules don’t break immersion; they deepen it. They offer players new ways to engage with the world, strengthen their emotional connection to the story, and make the unfolding events feel more personal and meaningful.

Flexibility in Rule Application

In previous sections, we’ve explored how optional rules can enrich the game and boost flexibility. However, there’s another important layer of flexibility often overlooked: the adaptability of the players themselves. Many players naturally modify even core rules to better fit their group’s needs, and this adaptability is one of the true strengths of tabletop RPGs. It’s also why optional rules are not nearly as disruptive as some critics suggest.

The reality is that players often treat even core rules as optional, adjusting them to match their group’s playstyle. This is especially common in games with more complex rule sets, like Burning Wheel or Vampire: The Masquerade. In Burning Wheel, for example, some groups simplify or omit certain mechanics to maintain the game’s pace or to better align with their preferred style of play. Likewise, in Vampire and other World of Darkness games, combat rules are frequently streamlined to focus more on the narrative and less on the mechanical intricacies.

This is not a flaw; quite the opposite! It’s a testament to the inherent flexibility of TTRPGs. These games are not rigid systems; they are flexible, evolving experiences that players and GMs shape together. When groups adjust even the core rules, they treat the system like a toolkit, just like they would with optional rules. This reinforces the idea that TTRPGs thrive on flexibility, and even foundational rules can be reshaped to fit the needs of the group.

So, when critics argue that optional rules disrupt the flow or imbalance a game, they overlook this essential truth: the beauty of TTRPGs lies in their adaptability. If players are already modifying core mechanics to suit their preferences, why should optional rules be any different?

This leads us to a deeper understanding of optional rules: they’re just one more tool in the expansive, flexible world of TTRPGs. Far from complicating things, they serve to enhance the experience, allowing groups to tailor the game to their desires.

The True Strength of Optional Rules

At the heart of tabletop RPGs is collaborative storytelling. Players and GMs work together to create narratives, explore new worlds, and engage in complex stories. The magic of this experience lies in choice, the ability to adapt the game to suit the group’s unique preferences and playstyles. Optional rules are the key to this tailored experience, providing a toolkit for customization, growth, and creativity.

Optional rules give groups the freedom to evolve the game organically, adding complexity or depth as desired, without overwhelming new players or disrupting the core gameplay. This flexibility is not just a feature of TTRPGs; it’s a fundamental strength. It encourages experimentation, making the game richer and more personal. It allows each group to leave its unique mark on the game, creating something truly special and tailored.

Instead of viewing optional rules as a threat to the game’s balance or integrity, we should embrace them for what they truly are: an invitation to explore, innovate, and customize. By offering a range of options without imposing a specific set of rules, they empower players to shape the game in ways that matter to them. But they also explicitly create no requirements; as optional rules, they can be freely ignored if you want. This is the essence of roleplaying, taking a system and creating your own experience.

In the end, optional rules embody the spirit of tabletop RPGs: freedom, creativity, and adaptability. They are not obstacles or sources of unnecessary complexity; they are bridges to more immersive, customized experiences. TTRPGs are not static systems; they are dynamic, living worlds that evolve with the people who engage with them. So, when critics claim that optional rules are disruptive or unnecessary, it’s important to remember that these rules provide extra room for the game to grow, adapt, and thrive.

By embracing optional rules, we embrace what makes TTRPGs so unique: the freedom to craft an experience that’s as dynamic and personal as the players themselves. Optional rules are not just tools! They are opportunities to create truly unforgettable stories. It’s up to us to make the most of them.

What do you think about optional rules and house rules? How do you adapt games for your table? What are some of your favorite optional rules and house rule revisions? Leave a comment below or come scream at Rev about his silly ideas over on Bluesky.

Share this with friends:
Related posts:
January 6, 2025
Rebutting the Criticisms of Rules-Light Systems
This entry is part 3 of 3 in the series TTRPG Defenses
Also be sure to check out the contrasting defense of rules heavy systems!

A Case for Simplicity and Accessibility

Rules-light tabletop role-playing games (TTRPGs) like Lasers & Feelings and Risus are often dismissed as overly simplistic, with critics claiming they shift too much work onto Game Masters (GMs) and fail to provide the structure needed for satisfying gameplay. But what if the very traits being criticized are actually the keys to their success?

Humans are natural storytellers. From improvised games of make-believe to spontaneous party games, we thrive on simple frameworks that let creativity flourish. Rules-light systems tap into this innate ability, offering a flexible canvas for narrative-driven play. The simplicity isn’t a flaw, it’s a feature designed to empower players and GMs alike by stripping away unnecessary complexity.

Rather than burdening GMs, these systems reduce cognitive load, eliminate hours of prep, and invite everyone at the table to share in shaping the story. Let’s explore why these games are not only manageable but liberating, and why many criticisms stem from assumptions rooted in traditional TTRPG design.

Reducing Cognitive Load: Why Simplicity Eases the Burden on GMs

Critics of rules-light systems often argue that they force GMs to make constant rulings and interpretations, potentially leading to decision fatigue. However, this overlooks the key benefit of simplicity: reduced cognitive load. Rules-light games like Lasers & Feelings and Risus free the GM from the complexity of stat blocks, modifiers, and intricate mechanics, allowing them to focus on the creative aspects of storytelling.

Streamlined Mechanics

Traditional systems demand GMs juggle stat blocks and detailed combat mechanics. In contrast, rules-light systems simplify these elements, focusing only on the essentials. For instance, an NPC or encounter might be reduced to a single descriptive phrase or a basic die roll, removing the need for exhaustive preparation. This reduced complexity allows the GM to make decisions more quickly and intuitively, freeing up mental space for creativity.

Natural Adaptability

Humans are naturally inclined toward storytelling and improvisation. In rules-light games, GMs rely on their natural creativity rather than memorizing rules. This taps into the brain’s inherent ability to make quick, adaptive decisions based on mental schemas, facilitating smoother gameplay. With less rule-based friction, GMs can focus on the narrative and character-driven moments, which are key to engaging players.

To enhance this natural adaptability, many GMs use tools like random generators, templates, oracles, or pre-prepared prompts. For example, random event tables or NPC generators can provide quick inspiration during gameplay, while narrative templates and answer oracles can guide story progression. Systems like Ironsworn or Motif integrate such tools directly into their design, offering structured ways to spark creativity without adding mechanical complexity. By equipping themselves with these aids, GMs can navigate ambiguity with confidence, ensuring that the story remains engaging and dynamic even when improvisation is required.

Tools For Bridging Gaps

While rules-light games rely on minimal mechanics, they don’t leave GMs without support. Many systems include optional guidelines or supplementary resources to help handle ambiguity. For instance, Motif uses dice-driven prompts to guide narrative decisions, while Ironsworn employs oracle tables to fill in story gaps. Such tools reduce the pressure on GMs by providing a scaffold for improvisation, ensuring that decisions align with the game’s tone and direction.

By combining simplicity with these aids, rules-light systems empower GMs to focus on the flow of the game and the shared story rather than the minutiae of mechanics. Far from being a source of stress, minimal rules create an environment where flexibility and creativity thrive, supported by practical tools that keep the experience accessible and engaging.

Empowering GMs: Flexibility and Player-Driven Storytelling

Rules-light systems empower GMs by providing the freedom to adapt and respond to the story as it unfolds. Instead of sifting through rulebooks to resolve situations, GMs can make quick, intuitive decisions that are in harmony with the narrative.

No Need for Extensive Prep

In rules-light systems like Lasers & Feelings or Risus, GMs don’t need to create detailed stat blocks for every NPC or monster. A “villain” can be defined by a simple die rating or a core concept, which keeps the focus on their role in the story rather than the mechanics behind them. This approach reduces cognitive strain and prep time, allowing the GM to stay engaged with the story and react dynamically. With fewer spoons exhausted and more free mental processing space, GMs can devote more attention to the unfolding fiction at the table.

Player-Driven Worlds

By giving players more control over their characters and the world, rules-light systems create a collaborative narrative. This shared storytelling reduces the GM’s burden of having to manage every aspect of the game. Players, in turn, help shape the story with their actions and choices, making the narrative develop organically. This collaboration also taps into social psychological principles, like the need for agency and belonging, which helps keep everyone invested and engaged without overwhelming the GM.

Experienced Gamers May Misinterpret Rules-Light Systems

Rules-light systems are often seen as more challenging by experienced gamers because they bring preconceptions from traditional, rules-heavy systems. These assumptions can lead to unnecessary confusion and difficulty in adapting. However, these systems also offer unique opportunities for seasoned players to explore new dimensions of gameplay.

Preconceptions About Structure

Players and GMs accustomed to detailed, rigid frameworks may feel disoriented when those structures are absent. They might start overcomplicating the light mechanics, seeking “missing” rules that simply don’t exist. This reaction often stems from a reliance on the cognitive ease of structure, where having more rules feels like it provides certainty. In contrast, rules-light systems require a mindset shift toward embracing simplicity and creative interpretation.

Adapting to Flexibility

For many, the lack of defined mechanics for every scenario can feel uncomfortable. However, it’s this very flexibility that makes rules-light games accessible, especially for newer players and GMs. Once the mental switch is made, GMs can focus on dynamic storytelling instead of rigid rules, and players are encouraged to engage more creatively. Psychological studies show that people adapt faster to environments where they can exercise more control, which is why rules-light and simple narrative-driven systems often feel more fluid and enjoyable once the initial hurdle is overcome.

Rules-Light as a Creative Break

For experienced players, rules-light games can serve as a refreshing departure from the mechanical complexity of traditional systems. These games allow players and GMs to shift their focus from rules mastery to experimental storytelling, encouraging new ways to engage with the narrative. For instance, a group that typically plays detailed systems like Dungeons & Dragons or Pathfinder might use a rules-light game like Fate Accelerated Edition or Index Card RPG for a one-shot adventure centered on character development or improvisational storytelling.

Tips for Moving From Heavier to Lighter Games

For players accustomed to heavier mechanics, transitioning to rules-light systems can be smoother with a few adjustments:
- Incorporate Optional Add-Ons: Many rules-light games, such as Fate, provide optional rules or modular expansions that add layers of complexity without undermining the system’s simplicity.
- House Rule Tailoring: Groups can create or adapt house rules to address specific needs or preferences. For example, adding a light resource management mechanic or a more structured initiative system can help bridge the gap for players who crave a bit more structure.
- Experiment with Short Campaigns: Start with shorter or standalone adventures to ease into the rules-light mindset. This lowers the stakes while giving players a chance to adjust to the new style.
By approaching rules-light systems with flexibility and an experimental spirit, experienced gamers can unlock their potential as tools for both creative expression and narrative exploration.

Accessibility for Newcomers and GMs

One of the biggest advantages of rules-light systems is their ability to welcome newcomers, making tabletop role-playing games more accessible than ever before.

Ease of Learning

Games like Risus are ideal for beginners because they don’t require players or GMs to memorize complex rules. With minimal mechanics to keep track of, everyone can focus on the storytelling and their roles within the game. This simplicity reduces the cognitive load on new players, allowing them to engage with the game without feeling overwhelmed. Additionally, newcomers can quickly understand how their actions translate into the game world, fostering a smoother learning curve and allowing for more immersive play.

Social and Psychological Benefits

Rules-light systems tap into our natural inclination for storytelling and playacting, which reduces the fear of “getting it wrong”. Players don’t have to worry about following exact rule interpretations or memorizing every detail. Instead, they can lean into creative decision-making and collaboration, which makes the experience less intimidating. Psychology shows that when people are given freedom to act and create in social settings, they experience lower levels of anxiety and more positive social engagement. This is why rules-light systems help players (especially new ones) feel more confident in their decisions, making them more likely to dive into the narrative and build the story together.

Addressing the “Burden on the GM” Critique

Critics often argue that rules-light games shift too much of the workload onto the GM, but this critique overlooks a crucial point: complex systems typically place a much heavier burden on GMs, requiring significant time and effort for preparation and rule adjudication. What’s often ignored in this discussion is how rules-light systems can support not only one-shots but also deep, long-term campaigns that engage players just as effectively as their rules-heavy counterparts.

Rules-Heavy Games Demand More Prep

In traditional, rules-heavy games, GMs can easily spend hours prepping for a single session. They have to craft detailed encounters, create stat blocks for every NPC or monster, and plan for a variety of contingencies. Rules-light systems, by contrast, eliminate much of this burden. With only a few core mechanics and flexible guidelines, GMs can improvise and adapt in real-time, saving time and mental energy.

This flexibility doesn’t come at the expense of depth. Systems like Fate Accelerated Edition demonstrate that minimal mechanics can still support long-term campaigns by encouraging collaborative worldbuilding, story arcs, and meaningful character development. The focus often shifts to narrative prompts and emergent storylines, allowing the players and GM to co-create evolving arcs. This approach reduces the need for extensive stat tracking while still delivering the kind of rich, layered stories associated with longer campaigns.

Freedom to Be Creative

Rather than constraining GMs with rigid rules, the minimal structure in rules-light systems empowers them to be more creative. With fewer rules to keep track of, GMs have the freedom to guide the story organically, responding to player actions and the evolving narrative. This fluidity allows for spontaneous storytelling and lets GMs make decisions based on the context of the moment, rather than trying to adhere to pre-established rules or mechanics.

For campaigns, this creativity can translate into the development of recurring villains, shifting alliances, or thematic story arcs, all without the need for complex mechanics. For example, GMs in Fate Accelerated Edition can deepen the gameplay by using simple “Aspects” and “Fate Points” to represent evolving character motivations or world changes. This means the focus remains on the story’s progression, rather than the mechanical grind of advancement.

Embracing the Light: Tips for GMs and Players

Transitioning to rules-light systems can be a refreshing change for both Game Masters (GMs) and players, offering a more flexible and narrative-driven experience. To facilitate this transition, consider the following strategies:

Interpreting Ambiguous Rules

Rules-light systems often leave room for interpretation, which can be both liberating and challenging. To navigate this:
- Establish Table-Specific Guidelines: Before gameplay, discuss and agree upon how to handle common scenarios. This consensus ensures consistency and reduces confusion during sessions. For instance, decide how to resolve contested actions or handle unexpected player choices.
- Embrace Flexibility: Understand that ambiguity is a feature, not a flaw. Use it as an opportunity to enhance creativity and adapt the game to the group’s preferences.
Encouraging Collaborative Decision-Making

Sharing the responsibility of rulings can enrich the gaming experience:
- Involve Players in Adjudication: When uncertain situations arise, involve players in the decision-making process. This collaborative approach fosters a sense of ownership and investment in the story.
- Promote Open Communication: Encourage players to voice their interpretations and suggestions. This dialogue can lead to innovative solutions and a more dynamic narrative.
Utilizing Supplements to Aid Improvisation

While rules-light systems are designed for flexibility, certain tools can enhance the experience:
- Random Generators: Utilize game tools that generate NPCs, plot hooks, or encounters, or provide answers to questions. These can serve as inspiration during sessions.
- Templates and Charts: Prepare templates for common scenarios (e.g., combat, social interactions) and charts for random events or outcomes. These resources can streamline gameplay and reduce decision fatigue.
- Prebuilt Story Seeds: Have a collection of story hooks or plot outlines ready to introduce new arcs or challenges, ensuring the narrative remains engaging.
By implementing these strategies, GMs and players can effectively embrace the flexibility of rules-light systems, leading to a more enjoyable and collaborative tabletop role-playing experience.

Long-Term Campaigns in Rules-Light Systems

Critics often argue that rules-light systems lack the depth necessary for sustaining long-term campaigns. However, many such systems are designed to support extended play by emphasizing narrative progression over mechanical complexity.

Story Progression Over Mechanical Advancement

In rules-light games, character and campaign development are driven by the evolving narrative rather than intricate mechanics. This approach allows for deep character arcs, complex storylines, and rich world-building without the need for extensive rules. For instance, in Fate Accelerated Edition, character Aspects and the use of Fate Points facilitate significant growth and change through storytelling choices, enabling campaigns to develop organically over time.

Optional Layers of Complexity for Campaigns

Some rules-light systems offer optional rules or modular expansions to add depth for longer campaigns. For example, Into the Odd provides straightforward mechanics but can be expanded with additional content to introduce more complexity as needed. Similarly, Knave is designed to be minimalist yet allows for the incorporation of more detailed rules to suit the preferences of the gaming group. These flexible frameworks enable groups to tailor the game to their desired level of complexity, supporting sustained engagement over extended play.

Narrative Tools to Maintain Engagement

To keep long-term campaigns engaging, GMs can employ various narrative techniques that supplement the minimalist rules:
- Recurring NPCs: Introducing characters who appear throughout the campaign can create a sense of continuity and deepen the story. Their evolving relationships with the player characters add layers to the narrative.
- Thematic Arcs: Developing overarching themes or story arcs provides direction and purpose, encouraging players to invest in the long-term progression of the campaign.
- Player-Driven Plots: Allowing players to influence the direction of the story fosters a collaborative environment where their choices have meaningful impacts, enhancing engagement.
By focusing on these narrative elements, rules-light systems can facilitate rich, immersive experiences that are sustainable over long-term play. The flexibility inherent in these systems allows for adaptability and creativity, ensuring that both players and GMs remain engaged throughout the campaign.

Recognizing Challenges and Limitations

Vital Caveat: It is important to recognize that the flexibility of rules-light systems can be daunting for some GMs and players. The lack of rigid structures or comprehensive mechanics might leave newer or less confident participants feeling uncertain about how to proceed. Ambiguity in rules can lead to decision paralysis for the GM or disagreements among players about how to resolve certain situations.

For those accustomed to the guidance of more detailed systems, adapting to the open-ended nature of rules-light play may require a significant mindset shift. These challenges, while real, can also be opportunities for creativity and growth. Rules-light systems encourage problem-solving, collaboration, and improvisation, which can be highly rewarding for those willing to embrace the learning curve.

It’s important to note that no TTRPG system or preference is universally “better” than others. Preferences vary based on playstyles, group dynamics, and the goals of the campaign. For those who thrive on structured mechanics, rules-heavy systems may feel like a better fit. Meanwhile, for groups seeking spontaneity and shared storytelling, rules-light games offer a unique and engaging alternative. Ultimately, the best system is the one that resonates with your table’s needs and enhances your collective experience.

Rules-Light Games Are a Feature, Not a Flaw

Rules-light systems are not a limitation! They are a gateway to more creative, fluid, and engaging tabletop role-playing. By stripping away unnecessary complexity, these systems free GMs and players from the burdens of rule-checking and number-crunching, allowing them to dive directly into the heart of the story.

For GMs, this means less time spent on preparation and more time spent crafting memorable, player-driven narratives. And for campaigns, the depth doesn’t have to come from more rules! It can emerge from rich character arcs, evolving storylines, and the natural interplay between players and the GM. Systems like Motif, Risus, Index Card RPG, Caltrop Core, and Fate Accelerated Edition exemplify how minimal mechanics can provide frameworks that support these deeper narratives without requiring extensive rulebooks.

Critics of rules-light games often misinterpret their simplicity as a weakness. The reality is that these systems empower GMs to adapt on the fly, lean into their improvisational skills, and foster collaboration. There’s no need to adhere to rigid frameworks or preordained scenarios. Rules-light games thrive on spontaneity, player-driven decisions, and creative problem-solving, making them easier to run for many (including many newcomers), not harder.

In fact, the real challenge for players and GMs alike is unlearning the assumptions carried over from traditional, more detailed systems. Once you let go of the need for complex systems and embrace the power of simplicity, you’ll discover that less really can be more: more freedom, more creativity, and more meaningful stories. Whether for one-shots or long-term campaigns, rules-light systems are an opportunity for fun, flexibility, and adventure.

What’s your experience with rules-light systems? Do they enhance your gameplay, or do you prefer the depth of traditional systems? Share your thoughts and let’s discuss! Comment below or come yell at Rev about it on Bluesky!

Share this with friends:
Related posts:
December 30, 2024